Slashgeo Log In
What Is the Geospatial Community?
posted by Satri
on Friday November 24, @01:45PM
Permalink
Trackback URI
Slashdotthis
Diggthis
Del.icio.us
from the sometimes-it's-better-not-to-ask-questions! dept.
from the sometimes-it's-better-not-to-ask-questions! dept.
Some weeks ago, Very Spatial asked for questions to answer over their great podcast. They mentioned my personal question during their 69th episode. Here's the question, and my tentative to answer it below. Of course, your input is more than welcomed! ""What is the geospatial community?" I ask "what", because I feel it includes the many sides of the question: - What's a community?
- What is the geospatial community?
- Who is in the geospatial community?
- Who is not in the geospatial community?!
- Why are some geospatial professionals not in the geospatial community?
- Should every geospatial professional be part of the geospatial community?
- What does the geospatial community do to be the geospatial community?
- Is the geospatial community geospatial?
- Is the geospatial community special?
- Is the geospatial community a Good Thing (tm)?
- Does it matter that a geospatial community exists?
- What is the present of the geospatial community?
- What is the future of the geospatial community?" Tentative answers below.
The first important thing to consider; I asked this question with honesty: I don't know the answer myself! :-) But since I may be forced to share my thoughts with Jesse, Sue and Frank over the podcast, why not get some preparation? Maybe it's because I mainly speak french that any preemptive analysis won't be bad? ;-)
- Who is in the geospatial community?
Hopefully, Wikipedia come to the rescue: "A community usually refers to a group of people who interact and share certain things as a group, but it can refer to various collections of living things sharing an environment, plant or animal. This article focuses on human communities, in which intent, belief, resources, preferences, needs, risks and a number of other conditions may be present and common, affecting the identity of the participants and their degree of adhesion."
The geospatial community shares the 'geospatial' as passion or work (or even better, both!). Those who are hobbyist exists in the community with various levels of integration. Most hobbyist and geospatial devices consumers won't probably actively participate to the community. Does that count them out? As for the geospatial professionals, they're quite diverse too. The reason is simple, geospatial technologies are extremely varied themselves, from remote sensing to GIS to GPS to geobusiness to webmapping to geodatabase management to virtual globes, etc. Just GIS is a whole world in itself. So yes, the professional geospatial community is fragmented. This is not necessarily a bad thing. It just means the overarching 'geospatial community' is composed of many 'subset' communities.
- Who is not in the geospatial community?! - Why are some geospatial professionals not in the geospatial community? - Should every geospatial professional be part of the geospatial community?
I guess the professional geospatial employee who just keep his eyes on his projects might be counted out of the community. To be part of it, you must at least have some interests in what's going on and why it's going on. I personally believe being active in the community is important. It allows us to be much more efficient. Communication and sharing has a lot of benefits. Then again, the goal for any worker is to find the appropriate equilibrium between 'taking the time to communicate and share' and 'do the actual work'. To answer my own question, I do believe every professional should be somewhat active in the community, and this might take various shapes.
- What does the geospatial community do to be the geospatial community?
Communicate and share as in a loosely defined group? This can happen during conferences, workshops, co-workers, collaborative software development, mailing lists, blogs entries and comments, etc.
- Is the geospatial community geospatial?
Mostly no. The geospatial community is mainly aspatial! :-) Anyone can participate no matter where they are. With globalization and information technologies, the frontier between countries is slowly getting fuzzier.
- Is the geospatial community special?
To be bold; no. It's just another technology-oriented community of practice!
- Is the geospatial community a Good Thing (tm)? - Does it matter that a geospatial community exists?
You bet! As I said, it allows us to be more efficient individually and collectively. And it can even be fun and enlightening to be part of such a community :-)
- What is the present of the geospatial community?
Very large, fragmented, exploding, diversified, etc. And I must say, a little disorganized. But this is positively changing (I'm an optimist ;-).
- What is the future of the geospatial community
I don't know. I know it's exploding. Geospatial is everywhere now (!!). Geospatial consumers tools are flooding the marketplace. This is having a significant impact on geospatial-everything, including the so-called geospatial community. Since "We create the future. With our words, our deeds and with our beliefs" (Babylon 5:"Signs and Portents"), I'm curious to see what our geospatial future is hiding for us...
So I guess the answer to the main question: "- What is the geospatial community?" lies in the various comments above. Comments?
- Who is in the geospatial community?
Hopefully, Wikipedia come to the rescue: "A community usually refers to a group of people who interact and share certain things as a group, but it can refer to various collections of living things sharing an environment, plant or animal. This article focuses on human communities, in which intent, belief, resources, preferences, needs, risks and a number of other conditions may be present and common, affecting the identity of the participants and their degree of adhesion."
The geospatial community shares the 'geospatial' as passion or work (or even better, both!). Those who are hobbyist exists in the community with various levels of integration. Most hobbyist and geospatial devices consumers won't probably actively participate to the community. Does that count them out? As for the geospatial professionals, they're quite diverse too. The reason is simple, geospatial technologies are extremely varied themselves, from remote sensing to GIS to GPS to geobusiness to webmapping to geodatabase management to virtual globes, etc. Just GIS is a whole world in itself. So yes, the professional geospatial community is fragmented. This is not necessarily a bad thing. It just means the overarching 'geospatial community' is composed of many 'subset' communities.
- Who is not in the geospatial community?! - Why are some geospatial professionals not in the geospatial community? - Should every geospatial professional be part of the geospatial community?
I guess the professional geospatial employee who just keep his eyes on his projects might be counted out of the community. To be part of it, you must at least have some interests in what's going on and why it's going on. I personally believe being active in the community is important. It allows us to be much more efficient. Communication and sharing has a lot of benefits. Then again, the goal for any worker is to find the appropriate equilibrium between 'taking the time to communicate and share' and 'do the actual work'. To answer my own question, I do believe every professional should be somewhat active in the community, and this might take various shapes.
- What does the geospatial community do to be the geospatial community?
Communicate and share as in a loosely defined group? This can happen during conferences, workshops, co-workers, collaborative software development, mailing lists, blogs entries and comments, etc.
- Is the geospatial community geospatial?
Mostly no. The geospatial community is mainly aspatial! :-) Anyone can participate no matter where they are. With globalization and information technologies, the frontier between countries is slowly getting fuzzier.
- Is the geospatial community special?
To be bold; no. It's just another technology-oriented community of practice!
- Is the geospatial community a Good Thing (tm)? - Does it matter that a geospatial community exists?
You bet! As I said, it allows us to be more efficient individually and collectively. And it can even be fun and enlightening to be part of such a community :-)
- What is the present of the geospatial community?
Very large, fragmented, exploding, diversified, etc. And I must say, a little disorganized. But this is positively changing (I'm an optimist ;-).
- What is the future of the geospatial community
I don't know. I know it's exploding. Geospatial is everywhere now (!!). Geospatial consumers tools are flooding the marketplace. This is having a significant impact on geospatial-everything, including the so-called geospatial community. Since "We create the future. With our words, our deeds and with our beliefs" (Babylon 5:"Signs and Portents"), I'm curious to see what our geospatial future is hiding for us...
So I guess the answer to the main question: "- What is the geospatial community?" lies in the various comments above. Comments?
Related Stories
Slashgeo: SlashGISRS.org and the State of Online Medias within the Community 5 comments
[+]
Today we offer you content and want feedback! Here's a presentation I made about SlashGISRS.org and the state of online medias within the geospatial community [look under files]. Read more below for the context, outcome and possible future. A lot of slashgisrs.org readers are community enthusiasts which also have their own blogs or at least have an opinion about blogging in the geospatial community. What do you think? As a starting point, some SlashGISRS challenges I identify in the presentation [pdf, 5.2Mb] are: "(a) Main challenge: in order to be special and worthed, slashgisrs.org must gather a critical mass of users to foster discussion, (b) act as a discussion aggregator: right now, insightful comments are scattered between numerous websites and (c) stimulate a sense of community: become a place for social exchanges and even friends making"
Slashgeo: Geospatial Blogs, Slashgeo's Future and Dilution 19 comments
[+]
Last week several blogs started discussing the state of online exchanges occuring on the geospatial blogs. This subject is very dear to me and important to Slashgeo's future. How will online communications evolve within the geospatial community? Is Slashgeo pertinent and what role should it have? Are there too many geobloggers? Read more below for my opinion and personal analysis.
What Is the Geospatial Community? 1 comment
[+]
Some weeks ago, Very Spatial asked for questions to answer over their great podcast. They mentioned my personal question during their 69th episode. Here's the question, and my tentative to answer it below. Of course, your input is more than welcomed! ""What is the geospatial community?" I ask "what", because I feel it includes the many sides of the question: - What's a community?
- What is the geospatial community?
- Who is in the geospatial community?
- Who is not in the geospatial community?!
- Why are some geospatial professionals not in the geospatial community?
- Should every geospatial professional be part of the geospatial community?
- What does the geospatial community do to be the geospatial community?
- Is the geospatial community geospatial?
- Is the geospatial community special?
- Is the geospatial community a Good Thing (tm)?
- Does it matter that a geospatial community exists?
- What is the present of the geospatial community?
- What is the future of the geospatial community?" Tentative answers below.
The State of the Geospatial Community: A Followup
[+]
Several blogs have expressed thoughts on the state of the geospatial community during the last week. It started with the GIS Dev Cafe entries one, two and conclusion on the GIS community. You then have Vector One, Dave Bouwman and The Memory Leak's comments on the geospatial community. All entries are worthed the read. In last November, I shared my own personal thoughts on what is the geospatial community. I was interview by the Very Spatial team (at a moment when I was quite sick - I'm surprised the interview has not come out worst than it is), you can listen to the 30-minutes podcast which includes insights from David Maguire of ESRI, Kavita Pandit, current President of AAG, Kathleen Ridgely, New Media Director of National Geographic Magazine and from the Very Spatial crew themselves. I finally took the time to listen to it (I still have 15 VS episodes to catch up). I believe this topic is very interesting. What are we as a community? Is our diversity a strength or fragmenting us? How can we improve our community to help fulfill its potential?
This discussion has been archived.
No new comments can be posted.
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.





Diversity as a strength
(Score:2)( http://alexandreleroux.blogspot.com/ | Last Journal: Friday March 17, @04:07PM )